Translate

Wednesday 20 February 2013

Day 3 in the Oscar Bail/Trial continues in SA today...(UPDATE: 21.02.2013)

As the 3rd bail hearing in the Oscar Pistorius case continues in the Pretoria Magistrates Court today, the state's main witness Hilton Botha has literally been torn apart by Oscar Pistorius' attorney Barry Roux as he's cross examined as we speak.
Oscar Pistorius looks drained, tired and devestated as he fights for his freedom in court...Oscar Pistorius continues to sob throught out the hearing, as evidence is layed out against him...

Lead investigator in Oscar's case, Hilton Botha:
Photo: Just to make sure now...

You all know who 'Botha' is?

Hilton Botha is the investigating officer for this case.

Photo: Botha says that the toilet itself is to the left in the toilet room. He says the bullets were fired diagonally through the door.
 
But Steenkamp's injuries were on her right side. Botha says this indicates that she was standing "hiding" on the righthand side of the toilet room – and was not sitting on the toilet.
 
The placing of the toilet room within the bathroom matches how the prosecution and defence has described it, but I can't confirm yet that the rest of the bathroom is as Jacaranda FM shows it in this graphic.

Here is a tweet showing the plans of Pistorius's house projected on screen in the courtroom. 

House plans... #OscarPistorius pic.twitter.com/RywrWKzT
Plans of the home, brought in as state evidence, indicates "murder" trail...

Photo: http://www.jacarandafm.com/kagiso/content/en/jacaranda/jacaranda-gallery-popup?oid=1836327&sn=popup&ugc_order=desc
Evidence of alledged "murder" trail...

Photo: Illustration of the gun used...

http://www.jacarandafm.com/kagiso/content/en/jacaranda/jacaranda-gallery-popup?oid=1836324&sn=popup&ugc_order=desc
Oscar's list of pending guns he's yet to receive...

An illustration of what alledgedly happend...



Follow on facebook live as he drama unfolds: http://www.facebook.com/#!/OscarPistoriusGuiltyNotGuilty



LIVE FEEDS OF ENCA NEWS REPORTER KARYN MAUGHAN AS SHE REPORTS LIVE FROM COURT: (CROSS EXAMINATION OF HILTON BOTHA BY DEFENSE ATTORNEY BARRY ROUX)

Roux appears to be trying to get Botha to admit that shots were not fired from basin, bit from the door.

Botha: but three of the cartridges were found in bathroom, only one in hallway.

cries as his advocate lays into Botha over his claims that witness saw OP light on after hearing shots.

Botha concedes that witness who heard 3 shots - then woman screaming - then 3 shots got number of shots wrong.

Botha concedes that unknown female witness didn't specifically identify Reeva and Oscar as sources of argument noise. ws

Botha: the witness's house is 600 meters from the house. Gasps from the public gallery. Roux: do you think that's fair?

Roux: did you ever take steps to ask for other phones, other than ones you found on scene? Botha unravels.

Roux tells Botha that "testosterone" found on scene was actually herbal remedy, not illegal substance.

Botha starts getting aggressive. Barely 20 minutes into cross exam and he's unravelling. Horribly.

Roux hammers Botha about fact that Reeva's bladder was empty when she died - evidence consistent with claims that she'd gone 2toilet

Roux: will you accept that would have felt more vulnerable without his prosthetic legs? Botha: yes

Roux is destroying Botha. This is like watching a baby seal getting clubbed.

Roux: have you ascertained who spoke to after shooting? Botha: not really

Roux: did you pick up the phone and check whether made a call to Netcare? Botha: no

Roux: called Netcare at 3:20am.

Roux points out that the security guard that spoke to on the phone heard him crying after he forgot to put phone down

Roux: it seems that there was an approach to disregard anything that could show a defense.

Prosecutor Gerrie Nel stares down as Botha concedes on almost every ground raised by Roux

Roux: there were no signs of an assault on Reeva's body and no signs of her defending herself from assault? Botha: that's correct

Botha says he couldn't find anything on crime scene inconsistent with accidental shooting version.

FOLLOW KARYN MAUGHAN: https://twitter.com/karynmaughan


Meanwhile it's said that if Oscar Pistorius should be found guilty on murder charges, that he will be allowed to keep his prosthetics legs, governement insists that they do not discriminate against prisoners wtih disabilities.

Oscar Pistorius is adament that forensic evidence will proove that he's not guilty of murdering Reeva Steenkamp in 'cold' blood ...


THE OSCAR PISTORIUS'S BAIL HEARING GETS INTERESTING!
21.02.2013

CHIEF WITNESS: INVESTIGATING OFFICER HILTON BOTHA, FACES 7 COUNTS OF ATTEMPTED MURDER!


IO Hilton Botha faces 7 counts of attempted murder

Chief Investigating Officer in the Oscar Pistorius murder trial...

Oscar Pistorius while in court...

The investigating officer in the Oscar Pistorius murder case has seven charges of attempted murder against him.
This was confirmed by the police on Thursday.

Senior police spokesperson, Brigadier Neville Malila, says detective Hilton Botha was first charged in 2009.

Malila says police were advised by the director of public prosecutions on Wednesday, that Botha was being charged.

Botha is the investigating officer in the murder of Reeva Steenkamp, who was allegedly killed by paralympian Pistorius on Valentines Day.

Her memorial service and cremation was held in Port Elizabeth on Tuesday.

Criminal expert, Eldred de Klerk, says this new development on the investigating officer will, without a doubt, have an impact on the case.

Amidst the scrum of journalist, Oscar Pistorius has arrived...

Carl Pistorius and defence lawyer Barry Roux talk during Oscar Pistorius's bail hearing on 20 February.
Defense attorney Barry Roux and Oscar's brother Carl talk whilst yesterday's bail hearing...

THE GUARDIAN'S LIVE COVERAGE AS IT HAPPENS IN COURT VIA TWITTER:

Lucy Bannerman (@Lbannermantimes) February 21, 2013
He has arrived. Somewhere inside that scrum sits #Oscar #Pistorius.. twitter.com/Lbannermantime…
Mandy Wiener of South Africa's Eyewitness News reports that the court is still waiting for Botha to arrive.
While the court is adjourned, I'll just mention that Nike has confirmed it has suspended its contract with Pistorius.

Mandy Wiener (@MandyWiener) February 21, 2013
#OscarPistorius Gerrie Nel, true to form, cracks a dry joke, saying 'there goes my case'.
— Daniel Howden (@howden_africa) February 21, 2013
Prosecutor jokes 'there goes my case' as #pistorius arresting officer summoned
The court adjourns for 15 minutes to bring Botha in.
Nair says he is concerned his plan for the morning has been thwarted. Is Botha here, he asks.
— David Smith (@SmithInAfrica) February 21, 2013
Nel: "He's in the court building. I'm in contact with him. He wished not to be here now." Nair: "Am I allowed to recall him now?" Yes.
— Alex Crawford (@AlexCrawfordSky) February 21, 2013
#oscarpistorius Magistrate asks for Investigating Officer Botha to be brought to court

Prosecutor Gerrie Nel starts by saying he wants to put certain things on the record.
He says it became known to him and the rest of the prosecution team yesterday that Botha faces seven charges of attempted murder. They didn't know that when they called him, he says.
— David Smith (@SmithInAfrica) February 21, 2013
The mystery woman is told about procedure, collects her plastic bag and walks across the court to the exit. Nair frowns at it all.
She wants Pistorius's mental health to be evaluated and proceedings to take place in camera. She is told to go and to take her appeal to the high court.
— Barry Bateman (@barrybateman) February 21, 2013
#OscarPistorius Nair says there are rules and we won't be hearing any app from anyone other than the counsel involved. BB
Nair says he has allowed the woman to speak, even though he did not have to.
— Alex Crawford (@AlexCrawfordSky) February 21, 2013
#oscarpistorius Magistrate says 'we are at an advanced stage. Not in interest of justice.'
A woman wants to bring a "constitutional application" to the court. She is a non-practising female attorney who says the constitution of South Africa is affected by the case. The application "addresses Pistorius's mental state". The judge, prosecution and defence are all unhappy. Both Nel and Roux (for Pistorius) protest.
— David Smith (@SmithInAfrica) February 21, 2013
A female South African attorney is standing up, quoting the constitution, describing a motion she brought and baffling magistrate Nair.
Updated
Apologies. Gerrie Nel, the prosecuting lawyer, said he wanted to address three issues before proceedings start.
Nair says he wants to address three issues before proceedings start.
Magistrate Desmond Nair has entered the court, followed by Pistorius.
— Mandy Wiener (@MandyWiener) February 21, 2013
#OscarPistorius Stands in the dock, hands clasped before him, staring forward as photographs file past and glance at him.
— Barry Bateman (@barrybateman) February 21, 2013
#OscarPistorius enters the dock. He stands, staring at Nair. BB
My colleague David Smith reports that Pistorius's father Henke is in his usual seat on the front row. The defendant's brother, Carl, looks "relaxed and upbeat", David says.
The media have been allowed to record proceedings for later playback today. 
Jacaranda FM are now reporting that Hilton Botha and the police have both denied dropping Botha from the case.
But the police will be bringing in a "provincial task force" to "bolster" the prosecution's case against Pistorius, the radio station says.
South Africa's Jacaranda FM is reporting that Botha has not been dropped from the case, citing police brigadier Neville Malila:
— Jacaranda Newsteam (@Jacanews) February 21, 2013
Investigator Botha says he doesn't know about him being dropped for the #OscarPistorius case
— Jacaranda Newsteam (@Jacanews) February 21, 2013
Investigator Botha says he is ready for the #OscarPistorius case, but have not yet spotted him here at the court
— Jacaranda Newsteam (@Jacanews) February 21, 2013
Col. N Malila: "we have not made the decision to drop Hilton Botha from #OscarPistorius case"
— Jacaranda Newsteam (@Jacanews) February 21, 2013
"Col. N Malila: We made a decision to Bolster the investigative team on Monday afternoon." #HiltonBotha #OscarPistorius
AFP is reporting that Botha has been dropped from the case. We can't confirm that at this point. More details soon ...

FOLLOW SOURCE:http://m.guardian.co.uk/world/blog/2013/feb/21/oscar-pistorius-bail-hearing-day-three-live-coverage

No comments:

Post a Comment